Paging Peggy Lee: Is This All There Is?


Guest post by Jonathan Dalton~

Over the past several months I’ve found myself inexorably withdrawing from the real estate blogging world. It’s not that I have issue with what’s being written or the issues being debated. Rather, it’s a growing sense that it’s all been said. And after a while, purely academic debates lose their luster.

Take the recent series on Agent Genius by Danilo Bogdanovic, “The Future of the Real Estate Industry.” Danilo’s basic premise, stated in the very first paragraph, is “it’s obvious that the real estate industry is changing?”

In this case, obvious is in the eye of the beholder. Put another way, the more things change, the more they stay the same.

One day in the near future I’ll write about Charles Schwab and the impact it had on the way stock commissions were viewed … and the reality that thirty years after the so-called revolution, full-commission brokerages remain in business. Dented and bruised, perhaps, but not because of the “necessity” of change.

But to do so would be to destroy my own basic premise that it’s all been said. Divorced commissions, standards of entry, commission rates (as much as can be discussed without raising the ire of the Department of Justice), the much-heralded and largely meaningless DOJ vs. NAR suit (one of the most widely misunderstood cases in recent history), hyper-local blogging, blogs vs. static sites, the worth of social media …

We in the real estate blogging world have been discussing these issues for the past few years. (My own blog, AllPhoenixRealEstate.com, will celebrate its second anniversary just past the first of the year; a Realtown blog preceded it by six months.) And what is becoming increasingly apparent is we’re talking largely to ourselves.

The general public has little interest in these back-stage conversations. Transparency isn’t useful when people aren’t engaged by what they see.

For that matter, the larger population of real estate agents has little interest in what we’re discussing on the blogs. And maybe that’s as it should be. The vast majority of agents have no interest in our internecine debates about the necessity of changing commission structures because their own commission structure isn’t under pressure.

They realize what the rest of us often forget – there are no absolutes. There are no “have to’s.” There simply are choices to be made based on our perception and interpretation of current conditions. Authoring a blog doesn’t convey any extra authority, much as many of us tend to believe. It just means we have a vehicle for our opinions.

At this stage, I’ve read them all. Wake me up when there’s something new.

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

[Post to Twitter] Tweet This Post 

  • Disturbingly on the money, JD.

    Nice to see you here, by the way.
  • Interesting. And I tend to agree- if you are hollering, or whispering, into the echo chamber, then maybe that is all there is. Then again, nearly every week someone contacts me through some means or another- a real estate agent who has just discovered blogging, and all these conversations are new and exciting to someone else and that's contagious, if you allow it to be.

    Also, if you are blogging to give information to a client, or blogging to articulate to clients the way you do business, or blogging to give an understanding of the business of real estate to clients, or blogging a listing, or even writing to encourage people to visit a hidden gem in your community, then I think there is plenty to write about, and even to rewrite about.

    There is always a chance that your boredom might be dependent on your audience.
  • I spent considerable time as an apostle (odd for someone of my ilk, I know), but was met with mostly blank stares.

    I wasn't talking so much about what I can write about on my own blog ... as many have claimed writers' block or asked their readers what they'd like to see when they ran out of ideas, I've kept plugging along for 30 months and counting.

    My thought was on the numerous tempests in teapots that we tend to view as serious issues despite their limited application ... few outside our world seem to care about the bulk of them.
  • Now I understand why I talk to myself so much :)
  • It's not because you're knee deep in snow? :-)
  • Blogging to and with other Real Estate and peripheral industry types for a couple of years will certainly wear one out, rehashing the same old, same old, does get rather boring. Buyers and Sellers however have a need for current information providing us with a never ending array of topics to address and a renewed sense of excitement when the adventure is viewed through their eyes.
  • I'll buy that, Laurie ... one of the mistakes I know I make is I don't revisit some topics often enough, forgetting that just because I've discussed something several times doesn't mean that my readers have seen it several times.
  • While there have been some arguments against the practice, updating relevant older posts and bringing them up in time is an effective way to communicate relevant info to buyers and sellers. It has been said that the average buyer/seller is involved in their real estate adventure for about 6 months, these days its probably a bit longer. We all have older posts that would be great information for buyers today. Sometimes it pays to update older posts. Just a thought for those days when we are blog/brain/dead.
  • This is an excellent point.

    The nature of blogging leads interesting & useful posts to be lost in
    archive hell. Perhaps a Page with links to all your best posts may help
    solve this problem, along with your suggestion, Laurie, to update & repost
    them from time to time.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Blog Widget by LinkWithin

Tweet This Post links powered by Tweet This v1.3.9, a WordPress plugin for Twitter.