Brand v. SEO: Which is More Important?


What’s more important for long term business success, a strong brand or strong SEO? Let me put it another way—Is it better that folks know your brand name and type it into the search engine box (Google) or that you appear on the first page of search results for your market keywords?

Google’s new search popularity measuring tool, Google Search Insights, measures search volume for keywords and is a good indicator of brand awareness and strength, (or lack thereof) – nationally, regionally, by state, by city and even internationally. Type in your brand and compare its search strength to your competitors.

Zillow v. Trulia: Battle of the Brands

When I played with Search Insights, I compared Trulia and Zillow and concluded that Zillow has a stronger national brand than Trulia, based on Google search volume. This means that consumers are more often typing keywords containing “Zillow” than keywords containing “Trulia”. How important is this, now or in the future?

Perhaps Zillow would rather have folks type in their brand name rather than find them after typing “New York real estate”. While Trulia may be on the first page of Google for “New York real estate” today (and not Zillow), it may not be there tomorrow. Strong SEO is undeniably good, but it must be constantly worked on. Being a Google first page champion is not a permanent title. You have to constantly fight off interlopers, who are discovering and using your SEO secrets to knock you off the coveted first page.

Although having a strong online brand is not a guarantee of success, it may be a ticket to survival, as more players enter the fray to fight over the search engine traffic. Maybe building brand strength will save you from the scars of the SEO wars. SEO may win the battle and brand the war. I definitely have to give this some more thought.

Using Google Search Insights in your business marketing

I think your marketing plan ought to include building your brand awareness, as well as building Google rank with SEO.

Use Google Search Insights to:

  • compare your brand strength to your competition’s–nationally and locally
  • market your business in areas where your brand is strong and work on building up your brand where it is weak.
  • promote your brand dominance with Google’s stats. Folks may not trust your company stats, but they will trust Google’s.
  • discover which states send the most traffic to your brand and market there
  • check “Rising searches” to see who may be gaining on you or how off brands are performing
  • discover the search terms associated with your brand
  • check your international search popularity.

Here’s a search volume comparison between RE/MAX and Century 21.

Take a look at the city results. RE/MAX apparently rules Cincinnati …

… while Century 21 does much better in New York. (this stat may help agents decide which brokerage brand to work with)

Rising searches for REMAX & Century 21 show regional/specialty brand performance:

How have you used Google Search Insights?

Further Blogger Insights on Google Insights:

The Future of Real Estate Marketing: Digging into the National Real Estate Search Scene

The Seattle Specialist: Google Insights maps where people search

The Future Buzz: Google Search Insights: A Look at Social Media Trends

Fun With Google Insights and Unified Communications (JasonKolb.com)– examining international search results

Google Search Insights: What can be learned from Google’s new trend spotting tool (Trendsspotting)

Using Google Search Insights to Determine App Popularity (the app gap)

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , ,

[Post to Twitter] Tweet This Post 

  • If you are a lesser known company or a new business and are looking for a foothold in the industry, it really helps concentrating on SEO. Even if you do not wish to hire a specialist, optimizing your pages just takes a little bit of research for related keywords.
  • A really interesting use of Google Search Insights (GSI) from a brand perspective. Thanks for the tips. I found that GSI fails to capture minute search traffic which would be insightful for small but growing realtors. It would certainly help mid-large sized realtors but fails to capture search popularity analytics for small sized realtors that are at a majority.
  • Good point Tony. Perhaps Google can refine the tool to get the small
    traffic, at least in the city filter.
  • The point made by SEO Company Pune is good. It highlights the different times and phases of a company life-cycle to apply different strategies: when new, it's good to get attention and SEO may be the most attainable way to do that until you can afford a solid branding effort.

    One way I'm using GSI is to determine the relative value of similar terms ("homes" vs "real estate" for an obvious example), segmenting that geographically and using the resultant information to inform SEO and paid advertising. Very helpful so far.

    Great article.
  • Thanks for the link - agreed that building your brand is vital, but if you look at how some big brands pan out in search versus the traffic you'll see SEO still matters. Not for the big terms, for the long tail. Pretty important, as people type in all sorts of crazy search strings that you'll want to come up for. Anyone who has a content heavy .com knows how beneficial lots of content us.

    Why not build both your SEO and your brand simultaneously? It's certainly possible !
  • Yes, I agree that you should build both. And I agree with G. Dewald that
    young companies need the SEO . No doubt. But I think the tendency for
    online companies is to focus on SEO and neglect brand-- that the first page
    of Google is marketing nirvana.

    The way I see it, SEO is somewhat passive marketing-- you must (1) wait for
    someone to type in the keywords to find you and then (2) they have to click
    your site (as opposed to others on the page) and (3) they must stick (not
    jump to another site) . With a strong brand, consumers go directly to your
    site and I think it more likely they will stick.
  • Great connection between building and managing a brand, and SEO. Your tips are great, and timely as I am currently working through many of these thoughts now in my business.

    George
  • Joe
    HomeGain did very well in California (better than Realtor.com and Zillow)
    http://www.google.com/insights/search/#cat&q=ho...
  • I typically hate leaving these types of comments, but it's just too true for this scenario: GREAT post. Really insightful. I didn't even think of using Google Insights for such a test.
  • Thanks Tanner. I have been playing with it and have discovered a lot of
    interesting stats. Now, if Yahoo had such a tool, it would be interesting
    to compare the 2.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Blog Widget by LinkWithin

Tweet This Post links powered by Tweet This v1.3.9, a WordPress plugin for Twitter.